The Confusing Case of Judy Smith

In 1997, something very unusual happened to Judy Smith, a 50-year-old nurse from Boston. She disappeared during what should have been a simple trip to Philadelphia with her husband Jeffrey, and what happened next has left people wondering for years.

The Trip to Philadelphia

Judy and Jeffrey had only been married for five months when they planned their trip. Jeffrey, who was a lawyer, needed to speak at a conference at the Doubletree Hotel in Philadelphia. Judy was excited because she had never been to Philadelphia before and wanted to see the city’s historical sites and do some shopping.

On April 9th, they went to catch their flight at Boston’s airport, but Judy realized she had forgotten her driver’s license at home. She told Jeffrey to go ahead without her, and she would take a later flight after getting her license. Jeffrey said Judy arrived at the hotel that evening and even brought him flowers to say sorry for the mix-up.

The Disappearance

The next morning, April 10th, seemed normal at first. Jeffrey went down to have breakfast while Judy was in the shower. They agreed to meet back at the hotel around 5 PM to get ready for a party. But when Jeffrey returned that evening, Judy wasn’t there.

Jeffrey looked everywhere for her. He knew she had planned to take a tour bus around Philadelphia that day, so he even hired a taxi to drive along the bus route to look for her. He went to the police, but at first, they said it was too early to report her missing.

Strange Sightings

Over the next few days, people reported seeing Judy in different places. Some said they saw her in Philadelphia, acting confused. Others spotted her at a mall in New Jersey, about 22 miles away. At the mall, she was carrying her favorite red backpack and trying to buy clothes. She was saying things that her family confirmed were true, like how her daughter rarely liked the clothes she picked out for her.

A Shocking Discovery

Five months later, on September 7th, 1997, two hunters made a startling discovery in North Carolina’s Mount Pisgah National Forest, about 600 miles from Philadelphia. They found human remains wrapped in a blue blanket. Using dental records, doctors identified the remains as Judy Smith.

The scene raised many questions. Judy was wearing hiking clothes and boots her family had never seen before. She still had most of the money she took with her ($167 out of $200), and she was wearing her wedding ring. But her red backpack and ID were missing. The police determined she had been murdered.

More Mystery

Strangely, people had reported seeing Judy near Asheville, North Carolina, in the days after she disappeared from Philadelphia. One shop worker remembered talking to her – Judy told the worker her name and mentioned her husband was at a conference in Philadelphia. She said she “just decided to go to the Asheville area.”

What makes this case so puzzling is that no one knows:
– How Judy traveled 600 miles to North Carolina
– Why she went there
– How she paid for new clothes and travel since she didn’t use her credit cards or bank account
– Why she never contacted her family

A Sad Ending

Judy’s husband Jeffrey passed away in 2005, never knowing what happened to his wife in those final days. Her children still don’t have answers about their mother’s strange journey and death. They remember something their mom used to tell them: “If you’re late or lost, it’s not a big deal, just make sure you call because not knowing is the worst part.”

The person who killed Judy has never been caught. While police have looked at some suspects, including a man who killed other hikers in the same forest years later, they haven’t found enough evidence to solve the case.

This mysterious case shows how someone’s life can take an unexpected turn, leaving their loved ones with questions that might never be answered.

===

SOURCE: “The Confusing Case of Judy Smith” by Crystal Dawn for Lost N Found Blogs: https://tinyurl.com/43zvka2l